I'm one of the few people who like the whole Player vs monster thingie but I too have some remarks. I think it would be better if monster kinships would be allowed. Most of the freeps come in already organized kinships with well organized tactics and then it's no wonder pvmp isn't really interesting. What do you guys think?
I think your idea is ok and I too like the monster play generally. Monster play just seems like a good way to handle PvP in the world where PvP is not easily implemented. I'm more for a separate PvP server though . I wouldn't go there because I don't play LOTRO for PvP, but it would be a nice place to get rid of those who want nothing but.